Why the introduction of an unprecedented quarantine in China a bad idea?


2020-02-04 18:40:12




1Like 0Dislike


Why the introduction of an unprecedented quarantine in China a bad idea?

Transporting patient with coronavirus in China

An Outbreak of coronavirus in China became the reason of unprecedented quarantine in the history of our species. During the last major outbreak all infected were quarantined in hospital wards or at home. It is not surprising that the Chinese government's decision to stop the spread by quarantine major cities in Hubei province is of concern to many epidemiologists. The fact that such a decision can create a lot more problems than the infectious disease outbreak and can even worsen the already difficult situation in China.

what has led To the isolation of millions of people?

Some experts in the field of health, including Lawrence Gostin, in an interview, arguing that mass quarantines can actually worsen the crisis.

Theoretically, to isolate the viral outbreak can be a ban on the movement of people from the epicenter of the outbreak in other regions. But the introduction of quarantine in China may prove too ambitious — according to the latest estimates, the events are attended by at least — as well as failure. The fact that the end of January in China traditionally falls on the celebration of the new year according to the lunar calendar. At this time millions of citizens of China travel the country and go abroad. So, immediately before closing of Wuhan city, it left at least 5 million people.

Other researchers are also concerned about the ability of Chinese authorities to control the movement of millions of people who are in closed cities. These people are probably scared, and no doubt desperately trying to protect themselves and their families. According to The Conversations, doctors in medical institutions like Wuhan are in a "state of war", and in several cities of China completely stopped the movement of public transport.

Streets of Chinese cities today look like

Moreover, critics of mass quarantine I believe that the argument in favor of the closure of the cities is based on the dangerous assumption that the risk of infection of one person is the same as the risk of another, just because these people live in the same region. However, in reality, especially in the early stages of outbreak, there are high-risk groups and for health of those people required close monitoring. Such measures should be taken before you will consider other radical strategies. Moreover, the introduction of so large-scale quarantine violates the rights of other citizens of China.

to always stay up to date with the latest news from the world of scientific discoveries.Yu subscribe to our

According to many researchers, instead of mass quarantine will be much more effective measures to monitor contacts at risk, educating the population, the use of drugs and protective equipment , as well as access to continuous and effective communication of patients with health services and hospitals. In reality, Chinese hospitals were crowded with people — long lines in hospital corridors and crowded in the period only contributes to the spread of infection. So, the first week of quarantine has led to mass panic, food shortages and medical supplies.

Coronavirus captures the world?

Meanwhile, despite the measures taken, cases of coronavirus have been registered in 24 countries including Russia. As reported , the Ministry of health introduced a coronavirus in the list of the most dangerous diseases, simultaneously closing the border in the far East, and restricting air and railway communication with China. In the United States, the Centers for disease control (CDC) has passed in a mode of emergency response. All passengers arriving from infected areas in international airports are thoroughly checked and provided assistance and information to travelers going to Asia.

a Mass congestion of people for the infection to spread.

According to the study published in the journal , more than 75,000 people — ten times higher than the official confirmed cases — was infected with the coronavirus in Wuhan. As the researchers write in their work, as at 25 January 2020 in Wuhan were infected 75 815 people. While on 31 January the Chinese government announced that the disease exceeded the 9700 all over the country, including 213 deaths.

what do you think, will be whether the measures taken by China effective against the coronavirus? Let's talk about it in the comments and members

An Obvious discrepancy between modeled estimates and the actual number of confirmed cases in Wuhan can be due to a number of factors. These include a long incubation period and time required for confirmation of the diagnosis by laboratory tests. Researchers obtained the results also indicate that each infected 2019-nCoV, on average a person could infect two to three people. This means that the number of infected doubles every 6.4 days. Scientists are also concerned about major cities abroad with close transport links with China can become the epicentre of the outbreak.

Coronavirus in person

As for the good news, thenmortality from new at the moment is not comparable with the death rate from SARS — severe respiratory syndrome, the outbreak which occurred in 2003. To avoid infection, the CDC recommended to follow a number of simple but effective rules: wash hands thoroughly, especially after visiting public places, avoid crowded places, sneezing and coughing into a handkerchief. Be healthy!


Ions instead of a knife: a new way to treat tumors

Ions instead of a knife: a new way to treat tumors

Not always the latest news from China may be associated with the spread of coronavirus infection. This was confirmed by a message from the city of Lanzhou, which refers to the commissioning of a unique complex for carbon ion therapy that help to win ...

Why do blind from birth people do not suffer from schizophrenia?

Why do blind from birth people do not suffer from schizophrenia?

In fact, we know very little about schizophrenia. I realized this when I watched a lecture by Professor of neurobiology Stanford University Robert Sapolsky in which a scientist spoke in detail about the disease. So if you don't know what to look for ...

Scientists want to make an audio test for coronavirus, and you can already pass it

Scientists want to make an audio test for coronavirus, and you can already pass it

One of the main problems associated with the spread of the coronavirus, is that the tests COVID-19 not available to everyone. Because of this, the total number of cases in the world may be much higher than official statistics. Just look at what is ha...

Comments (0)

This article has no comment, be the first!

Add comment

Related News

Found the first asymptomatic carrier of the coronavirus

Found the first asymptomatic carrier of the coronavirus

At the moment, about 17,000 people are infected with the coronavirus, about 360 people have died from the disease. Now for a little over a month we hear in all the media about the new (2019-nCoV) outbreak which was identified in t...

What is the difference between a pandemic and an epidemic?

What is the difference between a pandemic and an epidemic?

Let's not forget that the history of mankind is a history of response to viruses the New coronavirus is sweeping the planet. Just recently, the world Health Organization (who) outbreak 2019-nCoV extraordinary international situati...

Restored if the cells of the lungs after people quit Smoking?

Restored if the cells of the lungs after people quit Smoking?

the results of the new studies prove that quitting Smoking is never too late. cigarette Smoking is one of the most life-threatening harmful habits ever acquired. For example, recently scientists have found evidence that within the...